In this op-ed for pv magazine, Will Driscoll examines the findings of a NERC report which show that the reliability factor known as frequency responseâ€”once seen as potentially challenged by added solar and wind powerâ€”is improving.
By Will Driscoll
The North American electric gridâ€™s annual checkup shows that it is becoming increasingly reliable, as solar and wind gain share, according to the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC).
For solar, one grid reliability factorâ€”frequency responseâ€”is of great interest because of concern, as stated in the report, that â€śa changing resource mix and increase in renewable resourcesâ€ť may have a â€śpotential impact on frequency response performance.â€ťÂ
Frequency response has steadily improved since 2013, as shown in the last two columns of this table (i.e., one or both measures are improving in each interconnection):
The report notes that inverters from solar and wind farms now provide frequency support, alongside the frequency support that has traditionally been provided by synchronous inertia from fossil-fired generators.Â (See, for example, a report on solar and frequency support, prepared by Californiaâ€™s grid operator, First Solar, and the National Renewable Energy Laboratories.)Â
The 2017 solar eclipse was another bright spot for solar, as â€śno issues developedâ€ť from the transitory loss of mid-day solar power, because utilities had planned for the occurrenceâ€”just as they do for cloudy days.
Beyond frequency response, the report covered all 13 of NERCâ€™s grid reliability metrics. NERC found that all metrics were either improving, unchanged, or stable, with the exception that the Texas Interconnection is expected to have tight reserve margins this summer.Â Even there, the report noted that â€śERCOT [the Texas grid operator] has a variety of operational tools to help manage tight reserves and maintain system reliability.â€ť
The report provided updates on two incidents related to California wildfires and solar PV inverters.Â After the first incident, related to a 2016 wildfire, NERC advised utilities to contact a specific inverter manufacturer to implement a reliability solution specific to that manufacturerâ€™s inverters.Â NERC also formed a task force that will produce a guideline for â€śinverter-based resource performanceâ€ť to support grid reliability.Â After the second incident, related to a 2017 California wildfire, NERC issued a follow-up to the first alert.Â
Beginning in 2021, NERC expects to collect data on solar generating units that are 20 MW and larger, as part of its Generation Availability Data System that now covers fossil units and is phasing in wind units.Â Utilities use the data for benchmarking the performance of their own generating units.
NERC was certified by the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission as the nationâ€™s electric reliability organization in 2006, pursuant to the Energy Policy Act of 2005.Â Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico are not included in NERC, although an Alaskan organization has an affiliate membership.
Will Driscoll, MPA, JD, is an energy and environmental policy analyst who has worked primarily for the U.S. EPA via the contractor ICF Consulting. His recent work is at SaveTheClimate.us.