Maryland is the fourth state to require smart inverters for rooftop solar, which allow more solar on the grid. States aiming for high renewables should do likewise, says a consultancy. A looming question: will smart distributed resources be compensated for providing grid services?
April 8, 2020
Maryland is following Hawaii, California and Minnesota in setting smart inverter rules for distributed solar and storage.
Smart inverters enable more rooftop solar on the grid. Hereâ€™s why: although adding rooftop solar with ordinary inverters can increase voltage on a distribution circuitâ€”potentially above the safe range shown by the two dotted lines in the image aboveâ€”smart inverters can help control voltage. By helping solve the voltage issue that higher levels of rooftop solar can cause, smart inverters can increase the amount of solar a distribution circuit can handle, an amount called the circuitâ€™s hosting capacity.
The Maryland Public Service Commission last week adopted the IEEE 1547-2018 standard for smart inverters, which the state will require for new distributed solar and storage starting January 1, 2022. Sunrun and the Energy Storage Association endorsed the new requirements, according to a press statement from the Interstate Renewable Energy Council (IREC). IEEE is a global standards-setting organization.
For states with high renewables goals, adopting smart inverter rules can help meet those goals by increasing hosting capacity, says the Center for Renewables Integration (CRI), in a report titled â€śItâ€™s time for states to get smart about smart inverters.â€ť The Center advises using a stakeholder process, as Maryland did, and â€śstart now to develop implementation plans.â€ť
The alternative method of increasing hosting capacity, by installing utility-supplied voltage regulation hardware, can be costly. â€śBeing able to add more capacity to the distribution system without incurring distribution upgrade costs is a core purposeâ€ť of smart inverters, said Harry Warren, who co-founded CRI and led Marylandâ€™s smart inverter stakeholder process, in a pv magazine interview. â€śIndustry is very interested in these collaborative processes in decision-making, so that maximum advantage can be obtained from these [smart inverters].â€ť
A looming question, for states that set smart inverter rules, is whether smart distributed resources will be compensated for the grid services they provide. The answer may partly depend on the smart inverter settings specified in state requirements, and whether third-party aggregators are allowed to aggregate distributed resources, and then compensate the resource owners.
In Pennsylvania, for example, a utility has proposed to â€śmonitor and manageâ€ť all newly interconnected distributed energy resources, without making a commitment to compensate the resource owners. Sunrun is challenging that proposal.
Four statesâ€™ approaches
Hawaii and California were the first states to set smart inverter rules, without waiting for the IEEE standard. Both states require activation of a smart inverterâ€™s â€śvolt-varâ€ť setting, which enables the inverter to independently regulate voltage. This required setting avoids the expense of a centralized utility communications system and distributed energy resource management (DERM) system. The consultancy GridLab advocates the volt-var approach in a report, which also provides details on the two statesâ€™ approaches.
Minnesota last fall became the first state to adopt the IEEE 1547-2018 standard in requiring smart inverters, as reported by IREC Vice President Sara Baldwin. â€śVolt-var was discussed substantially during the draftingâ€ť of the requirements, said IRECâ€™s Chief Regulatory Engineer Brian Lydic in a pv magazine interview, but he said that a different setting was specified, namely â€śconstant power factor mode with a 0.98 power factor.â€ť
â€śUtilities did not feel comfortable,â€ť Lydic said, â€śimplementing the dynamic [volt-var] function without doing a deeper study of how it would interact with their own distribution systems.â€ť Utilities also raised a concern about â€śbeing unable to easily change volt-var settings without a communications and control system in place.â€ť Lydic noted that IREC has advocated for the continued discussion of volt-var utilization in Minnesota as the stateâ€™s requirement evolves in the coming years.
In Maryland, smart inverter settingsâ€”volt-var or otherwiseâ€”will be established through a Phase III stakeholder process that will continue over the next two years.
Sunrunâ€™s Senior Manager of Public Policy Nicole Sitaraman said in a pv magazine interview that Sunrun participates in two Maryland workgroups, on interconnection standards and energy storage, that are â€śinvestigating pathways to enable distributed energy resources (DERs) to provide grid services.Â These working groups will also look at future utility plans to address hosting capacity, which should provide more opportunities for DERs in Maryland to modernize the grid and provide valuable cost savings services to the region.â€ť
The text of the Maryland Public Service Commissionâ€™s requirements is available here, starting on page 126 of the document.